MAVERICK JUDGE FROM SRI LANKA By Shahid Ali, Karachi. From The Pakistan Times, Monday April 3, 1989
Mr. Justice (Retd.) Rajaratnam from Sri Lanka, who is visiting Pakistan to participate in the International seminar on The Legacy of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, is one of the few foreign jurists who have made in depth studies…
Mr. Justice (Retd.) Rajaratnam from Sri Lanka, who is visiting Pakistan to participate in the International seminar on The Legacy of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, is one of the few foreign jurists who have made in depth studies of the Bhutto Trial. His findings were published last year in the form of a 288 page book titled “A Judiciary in Crisis? - The Trial of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto”. Mr. Rajaratnam did his bar from Lincoln’s Inn, and practiced law for many years before joining the judiciary. He served as a judge of the Sri Lanka Supreme Court from 1970 to 1978 when, under the new constitution promulgated by Mr. Jayawardene, the judiciary was reorganized. Mr. Rajaratnam is a sprightly old man and he attributes his enthusiasm for the rule of law to his rebellious heart. “I was a maverick on the Bench,” he proclaims with pride. This self acquired title has a story. He was hearing a human rights petition during Mrs. Bandaranaike’s premiership. The Chief Justice suggested to him that it would be inadvisable to give a verdict that might embarrass the lady in power. He was told that his chamber would be locked and he would be prevented from entering the court room. But Mr. Rajaratnam stuck to his guns and declared that he could deliver his judgement in a corridor on the court premises. In times of stress, the judges had a special duty to assert their right to give independent judgements, he said. And he won a point not only for himself but for the entire Sri Lankan Judiciary. The story does not end here. Mrs. Bandaranaike repaid the defiant judge by nominating him as one of her party’s representatives in the present Parliament. However, Mr. Rajaratnam is extremely critical of the Sri Lankan Judiciary’s performance during the years of the ‘long Parliament’ (1977-88). “ The huge majority Mr. Jayawardene’s UNP had won in the 1977 elections,” says Mr. Rajaratnam, “ was used by it to weaken itself-it took actions that raised grave constitutional crises”. The former judge refers to Article 161-E of the old Constitution whereby the life of the Parliament should have ended not later than six years after the polling. But instead of new elections by 1993, the Parliament extended its tenure for another five years. The issue was raised before the country’s Supreme Court which declined to give a ruling on the grounds that it had no jurisdiction on the matter. The country was deprived of the benefit of the wisdom of the court in its moment of crisis. The extension of the Parliament’s life through a referendum became one of the factors that gave rise to agitation and violence in Sri Lanka. Rajaratnam makes it a point to emphasize that all the crises Sri Lanka has faced in the recent years have erupted after July 1983 – the point at which the normal term of the Parliament elected in 1977 was to end. For instance, the youth (between 20 and 28 years of age) became restive. They were entitled to vote in 1983. Denial of this right pushed them into the politics of violence. Mr. Rajaratnam likens the journey of Democracy between 1983 and 1988 to a flight in rough weather. “The plane ran into air pockets quite frequently, and ultimately crash- landed in December 1988” he says. When asked about the Sri Lankan political crisis, Mr. Rajaratnam is quite categorical in his assertion that one of the principal reasons of the political turbulence was the breakdown of the rule of law. The Chief Justice and two other judges were arraigned before a parliamentary committee, thus compromising the status of the judiciary as an independent organ of the state. The report of the parliamentary committee was highly controversial. Then, with the court’s judgement on a human rights petition which resulted in Mrs. Bandaranaike losing her civil rights, a fundamental human right was denied. As regards the spread of violence in Sri Lanka over the past few years, Mr. Rajaratnam says: “You cannot prevent terrorism by resorting to oppressive laws. We had our Prevention of Terrorism Act and the relevant emergency regulations. The result was that terrorism escalated. Then a military solution to a political issue was attempted. That too, was bound to fail. The plain fact is that oppressive laws offer no solution to a political problem. The rule of law can only be enforced through normal laws.” Mr. Rajaratnam is especially keen to focus attention on the political implications of the 1977 elections in Pakistan, India, and Sri Lanka. “We were moving towards an order based on equity and social justice. The trend towards escaping from American bondage was clear. After July 1977, there was a complete swing to the Right. “ He leaves it to the people of the region to draw their own conclusions. RAJARATNAM HONOURED Sri Lankan Parliamentarian and former Supreme Court Judge T.W.Rajaratnam was honoured by the people of Pakistan and Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto’s Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) when he was invited to join a panel of international dignitaries to address a seminar held to mark the tenth death anniversary of former Pakistani Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. FORMER SUPREME COURT JUDGE TESTIFIES TO SOCIALIST HUMANISM Humanism is the philosophy of the Soviet People. Their concern for the well-being of their fellow citizens, the respect for equality as well as the upholding and consolidating justice are shining examples of this fact. The basis for the development of a society is justice and equality. And this is evident in the rapid development of the Soviet Union which is a multi-national state. Law and Justice are administered by the people. An interesting attribute of the Union is that rehabilitation programmes are conducted in respect of minor offenders. The Soviet Union is a peace- loving entity that really works for the cause of peace. But it should be said that in the face of imperialist manoeuvres, the strengthening of defence capabilities is necessary. These observations were made by T.W.Rajaratnam- former Supreme Court judge- at a meeting held on Monday the 12th October, 1981 at Colombo. T.W.Rajaratnam, who is a Vice- President of the Lanka- Soviet Friendship League, was a member of the delegation which visited the Soviet Union together with Shelton Ranaraja, the Deputy Minister of Justice. The meeting was presided over by T.B. Subasinghe, President of the Sri Lanka- Soviet Friendship League. Rajaratnam said that he was interested in the Soviet Union from his undergraduate days in the University of Ceylon. His first visit served to clear all doubts and discredit all negative accounts of the Soviet Union.