RELIGION AND RATIONALISM
Retired Supreme Court Judge T.W. Rajaratnam makes a strong case against fundamentalism whose roots go back to ancient times, and calls on the religious and rational to fight these tendencies. This is an excerpt of an…
Retired Supreme Court Judge T.W. Rajaratnam makes a strong case against fundamentalism whose roots go back to ancient times, and calls on the religious and rational to fight these tendencies. This is an excerpt of an article by him. When discussing Religion and Rationalism two questions have to be considered. One, whether Rationalism and Religion can co- exist, and two, if so does Rationalism subject itself to some qualifications and modification, and likewise, does Religion also subject itself to some qualification and modification? First, let us have some sort of consensus on the meaning of the terms “Religion” and “Rationalism”. Religion means a belief in, or acceptance of a persuasion or philosophy, which does not (more often than not,) exclude the supernatural. On the other hand, Rationalism is also a philosophy, if not a persuasion which propounds the theory that reason is the foundation of certainty in knowledge, and reason is the ultimate authority. In practice, Rationalism seeks to explain what may appear to be supernatural in a way consonant with reason. Where reason ends, belief begins. Hinduism is not one religion. It is the history, content and practice of many religions and thought ranging from animal worship to the highest Vedanta philosophy. It is polytheistic and monotheistic, it is rational and irrational, it is superstitious and non superstitious. It embraces Theism, Atheism, and Agnosticism. It is natural and supernatural. It embraces all religious thought. It is both a religion and a philosophy. It has everything and nothing, so to speak, on its Menu Card, and you can take what you like, or leave it. It culminates in Man being God himself, going beyond the concept of Man being made in the image of God. It also includes the concept of God being man. It is symbolic and non symbolic. The Rationalist sees the rational meaning behind the symbol, and the believer sees the idol as the reality. When one says he is a Hindu, it is far too general a term. In Hinduism, there is animal worship, the Brahmin cult, the caste tyranny, and the Priesthood. There is fundamentalism on the one hand, and the highest tolerance on the other. Buddhism grew on Hindu soil. It was the intellectual flower that blossomed on Hindu soil. The Vedanta philosophy is the spiritual flower that grew of Hindu soil. Though Christianity did not grow on a Hindu soil, the message of Christ is the message of Love, a message of Universal Love which, significantly, is the message in the essence of the intellectual and spiritual flowers, that is to say the essence of Buddhism and the Vedanta philosophies. Whether it is the Fatherhood of God, or the Brotherhood of Man, as preached by the Prophet, mankind belongs to one family; and man is involved with man. The Dhamma is a perfectly rational philosophy. Is it possible for a Rationalist to quarrel with the Four Noble Truths, And the Noble Eightfold Path? The Rationalist- if he does not like the term Noble- can call these concepts the Four Rational Truths, and the Eightfold Rational Path, Peace of Mind. Surely a Rationalist is not averse to peace in the world, and peace of mind! Why should a Rationalist quarrel with the message of Christ and the Sermon on the Mount? Why should the Rationalist quarrel with the concept of Divinity of Man- as expressed in the Vedanta philosophy? If he does not accept the concept of Divinity, let him amend it to the concept of the Dignity of Man. What is irrational in the teaching of the Prophet to the society of his times? The essence of all these teachings is rational. It is Love and Humanism. We are asked by the teachings of the Buddha to be compassionate and kind. We have been told that greater than the building of temples, lighting of lamps and offering of flowers, is one kind act to a fellow human being. We have been told to take a lesson from the bee that collects and keeps in reserve only that much honey from the flower that is sufficient for its sustenance, lest it damage the flower, and we are advised not to take from society more than we need, for the sake of the preservation and stability of society. Is there anything irrational in all this? Christ told the crowd who wanted to stone the fallen woman to death because she had sinned: “He amongst you who has not sinned- let him cast the first stone” Christ did not make a difference between Jew and Gentile. The Buddha said that a Brahmin is not one by birth, but by conduct. The teachings of Christ were critical of Jewish society; the teachings of the Buddha were in effect to reform Hindu Society. Was there anything irrational in all this? Was it not Love and Reason that motivated these great teachers? They had no vested interest to protect. What is irrational in the Brotherhood and the Way of Life preached by the Prophet and in his words of wisdom? Fundamentalists on the other hand, in every religion, have no use for the essence and spirit of the teachings of the masters. Rationalists can see them in the course of history as the cause of wars, bloodshed and horrible crime. These wars are invariably self motivated to safeguard their vested interests in established society. The revolution of October 1917 in Russia where comparatively only a few were killed is still called a Bloody Revolution, whereas religious wars continue to be called Holy Wars and Crusades, despite the casualties running into millions over the years, keeping man in bondage, ignorance and suffering. Fundamentalists survive and thrive on the ignorance of people, whom they keep brainwashed with their theories; and it is true that Fundamentalists largely contribute to man’s inhumanity to man. It helps the oppressors to continue the oppression of the oppressed with the help of the oppressed whose ignorance, superstition and fear of the supernatural are exploited by these so called religious purists. Ignorance, fear, superstition and the supernatural are the old timeless weapons of the Fundamentalists to avail themselves of the help of the oppressed themselves; and the fourth hand is waved to convey the reassuring message- “Do not fear”. Voltaire said we must not discard religion without finding a substitute for it. We will not venture to convert Mother Theresa to Rationalism without religion. Just as religion can breed the fundamentalist, Rationalism can also breed a fundamentalist and a fanatic. We must not throw out the baby with the bathwater. Religion must drive out the fundamentalist. It must be a concerted effort. The Rationalist can help in this noble endeavour.